“Self-Deleting Jews”

2011.08.16
By

(Feel free to skip if you’re not hot for ethnoapologetics.)

THERE’S AN UGLY MEME IN the Jewish community that may or may not have analogs among other minority groups: the so-called “self-hating Jew.”

This term, most often used in online Jewish fora (the Forward, Tablet, Jewschool, et al) when someone Jewish posts a critically outre comment about Israel, is more generally used to describe one who turns his or her back on “the tribe” and spends some significant time publicly railing thereupon. (Peter Beinart and Adrienne Rich come most prominently to this writer’s mind, but someone once used it to describe me when I naively asked in one forum, “Is there such a thing as ‘too Jewish?’” I don’t think so, but some apparently do.)

The self-absorption of my tribe notwithstanding (tribal politics arise from the idea that the most interesting thing in the world is what the other fellow’s doing, and usually that he’s doing it wrong), there are some Jews who just don’t like other Jews (or maybe even “being” Jews themselves). But I’ve always felt uncomfortable about the “self-hating” part of the descriptor. It’s too presumptive, and inaccurate — those tarred with such a brush don’t really seem to hate themselves. But they do seem to have it in for Judaism, or at least their fellow Jews.

Thus, I’d like to propose a new and better meme: the “self-deleting Jew,” one whose watchword is simply, if stridently, “I’m not with those guys.”

The learned Philologos has already discoursed on this topic, groping for his or her own metaphor; I’m just trying to float a new meme of my own. (Don’t worry about attribution, although it would be nice.) Some Jews’ only use for their heritage is to bash it with something. Alas! the poor souls are but self-deleting Jews. They deserve compassion rather than censure; it’s a fine line, however, between compassion and patronization.

“Self-deleting Jew.” Pass it on. Or better yet … don’t.

  • email
  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Add to favorites
  • Tumblr
  • PDF

Tags: , ,

6 Responses to “Self-Deleting Jews”

  1. Juliet Milkens on 2011.08.17 at 0743

    - I thought that Peter Beinart’s article in the NYRB on why young people are not attracted to the Jewish way of life/Israel was a fair appraisal – certainly based on my children and their friends. I don’t get how he comes to be characterized as self-hating or self deleting. Please explain.

    • Neal Ross Attinson on 2011.08.17 at 0910

      That’s a characterization I’ve seen more than once, more often by commenters than writers. I can’t judge Mr. Beinart’s NYRB article (haven’t read it), but in his other writings he seems to me to have the same relationship with Israel as Richard Dawkins has to God.

  2. Barbara Mazor on 2011.08.16 at 2140

    I really love this neologism. First is the rhyme with “self-defeating.” Then there is the idea of deletion. Deletion from the community. Deletion from history. It is sad.

  3. Chicky on 2011.08.16 at 1809

    I prefer to use ‘self-hating Jew’ in the way that Larry David does: As an affirmation of one’s willingness to be critical of anything and everything, who will stick by their opinions no matter how many Jews think otherwise.

    • Neal Ross Attinson on 2011.08.16 at 1824

      That’s a great definition, but I ask you — where’s the hate?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Tales

…And We’re Back

IT FEELS GOOD to write again. It has been just over six years since I last added to this blog (which once boasted a...

Read more »

Prosatio Silban and the Starving Survivor

A BUOPOTH IS A STRANGE beast: some say it is half-composed of men’s dreams, others prefer not to speculate. But of the little that...

Read more »

Prosatio Silban and the Visitor From The Sands

PROSATIO SILBAN WAS NOT KNOWN for nothing as “The Cook For Any Price.” He had long ago foresworn the Sacreanthood and serving people’s souls...

Read more »

The Poet

HE COULDN’T TELL WHETHER HE loved beauty or women more until the day he called his mom and said “Guess what? I’m marrying a...

Read more »

Storyteller’s Knot

THE MOST IMPORTANT PART OF any story is the point at which it’s attached to the reader.

Read more »

Recently

February 2017
S M T W T F S
« Jan    
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728  

Rewind

Wine Country Weather


Click for Forecast

Ritual Hat Pass

G'bless'ye, sir or madam.

You Can't Stop The Signal:
Celebrating the remaining days:hours:etc until Apophis II. Live it up, Earthlings.

Favicon Plugin created by Jake Ruston's Wordpress Plugins - Powered by Briefcases and r4 ds card.